“To say Charles Schwab is an entrepreneur is actually an understatement. He really is a revolutionary.”—Phil Knight, co-founder of Nike, author of Shoe Dog **
The founder of The Charles Schwab Corporation recounts his ups and downs as he made stock investing, once the expensive and clubby reserve of the few, accessible to ordinary Americans.**
In this deeply personal memoir, Schwab describes his passion to have Main Street participate in the growing economy as investors and owners, not only earners. Schwab opens up about his dyslexia and how he worked around and ultimately embraced it, and about the challenges he faced while starting his fledgling company in the 1970s. A year into his grand experiment in discounted stock trading, living in a small apartment in Sausalito with his wife, Helen, and new baby, he carried a six-figure debt and a pocketful of personal loans. As it turned out, customers flocked to Schwab, leaving his small team scrambling with scarce resources and no road map to manage the company’s growth.
He recounts the company’s game-changing sale to Bank of America—and how, in the end, the merger almost doomed his organization. We learn about the clever and timely leveraged buyout he crafted to regain independence; the crushing stock market collapse of 1987, just weeks after the company had gone public; the dot-com meltdown of 2000 and its reverberating aftermath of economic stagnation, layoffs, and the company’s eventual reinvention; and how the company’s focus on managing risk protected it and its clients during the financial crisis in 2008, propelling its growth.
A remarkable story of a company succeeding by challenging norms and conventions through decades of change, Invested also offers unique insights and lifelong principles for readers—the values that Schwab has lived and worked by that have made him one of the most successful entrepreneurs of our time. Today, his eponymous company is one of the leading financial services firms in the world.
Advance praise for Invested
“I’ve admired Chuck Schwab for a long time. When you read this book, you’ll understand why.” —Warren E. Buffett
“This is a fascinating story that teaches you about the never-ending evolution of an entrepreneurial company, but even more about personal learning from that experience. So read, learn how to learn from experience, and enjoy.” —George P. Shultz, former secretary of Labor, Treasury, and State
Review
“Chuck Schwab provides an engaging look into the investing world, balanced between his penchant for risk-taking with his grace and humility. He crafts a creative and highly rewarding story of not just Charles Schwab, the company, but Charles Schwab, the person. There are life lessons in this book for everyone, from Wall Street to Main Street.” —Condoleezza Rice, former U.S. Secretary of State and Denning Professor in Global Business and the Economy at the Stanford Graduate School of Business
“By turns practical and personally insightful, Charles Schwab’s indefatigable spirit, sound judgement, and entrepreneurial experience shine through in Invested. Throughout his childhood and career, Chuck overcame challenges and set a standard of leadership and innovation throughout decades of change in our U.S. economic system.” —Jamie Dimon , chairman and CEO, JPMorgan Chase
“Like myself, Chuck is a dyslexic. He learned early on that he had his limits and therefore—unlike most nondyslexics—discovered the power of delegation. He discovered that business is all about people who share your vision and values but bring their own passion and strengths to the tasks. He realized early on that the world is full of people more capable than himself in ‘a thousand different ways.’ Most leaders and entrepreneurs never learn that simple lesson. It was his dyslexia that helped him create one of the most successful companies in the US. Invested is a must-read for anyone interested in working in a business or becoming an entrepreneur. An extraordinary life and book.” —Sir Richard Branson , founder of the Virgin Group
“Charles Schwab is a giant who transformed finance and investing for millions of Americans. His memoir is a textbook case on entrepreneurship and principled leadership.” —Hank Paulson, 74th Secretaryof the Treasury
“Through Chuck’s unique perspective, Invested details Schwab’s history as they persevered through adversity while providing wisdom and encouragement along the way. I have admired and respected Chuck for many years. We share a passion for golf and how its challenges parallel those encountered in business.” —Phil Mickelson
“Chuck tells a story that very few can tell. It is a story of creativity, passion, and bravery trumping the odds. Chuck not only created the discount brokerage industry but grew a company in the face of market cycles and a rapidly changing and consolidating landscape. Chuck led the way in democratizing the market for the individual investor. I am proud to have been a partner with Chuck in the early days. I am especially proud to have him as a friend for the past fifty years.” —George R. Roberts, co-chairman and co-CEO, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts
“We learn best from the stories of others, and you’ll be hard pressed to find one so interesting, inspiring, and educational as this one! An enriching read from a great and principled man.” —Steve Forbes, chairman and editor inchief, Forbes
“Sharing his personal story of meeting and overcoming personal and business challenges that enabled the innovations enhancing the financial well-being of millions, Chuck Schwab’s Invested is full of invaluable insights into, and wise counsel about, building a successful business and successful personal investing. A readily accessible ‘real must-read’ for anyone interested in business and finance.” —Michael J. Boskin, professor of economics, Stanford University ; f ormer chair, President’s Council of Economic Advisers
“ Invested is a wonderful account of a textbook disruptor. By focusing on affordability and accessibility, what Chuck built in Charles Schwab has been a real blessing to mankind.” —Clayton Christensen , Kim B. Clark Professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School; author of The Innovator’s Dilemma
“For years Chuck Schwab was one of my fiercest competitors; now I consider him a friend. His book about building Charles Schwab into a revolutionary investment powerhouse is a must-read for anyone interested in what an audacious, high-integrity entrepreneur is capable of doing if he dreams big.” —Joe Ricketts, founder, former CEO, and former chairman, TD Ameritrade
“The fact that anyone in America can be an investor both enhances prosperity and reinforces the public’s buy-in to the concept of economic freedom. Few have done more to expand access to this form of direct participation in capitalism and free enterprise than my friend Chuck Schwab, and the story of how he did it belongs on the bookshelf of anyone interested in the evolution of investing over the past four decades.” —Paul Singer, founder of the Elliott Management Corporation
“From the beginning, one of Chuck’s great insights was that he could only create the business of his dreams by leaning heavily on emerging technologies. He bet big on data and never looked back. It changed investing forever.” —Thomas M. Siebel, CEO, C3.ai
About the Author
Charles Schwab is the founder, former CEO, and current chairman, of The Charles Schwab Corporation. Among the giants of the financial services industry, he is one of the most successful entrepreneurs and leaders in American business.
Tuesday, April 30, 1975. The day before what came to be known to people in financial services as May Day. I’m not sure if it was sunny or socked in with San Francisco fog. I had a lot on my mind. I do recall that investors had been in a good mood all spring. The Nixon impeachment nightmare was over, the Vietnam War was behind us, and the market was moving again; the Dow was up nearly 50% since late December. I’m sure I was as hopeful as anyone else. But I’d seen too much to believe the worst was over.
I was about to turn 38 in a couple of months. The Dow had been flirting with the magic 1,000 mark for the last 10 years, first breaking that milestone on November 14, 1972. At the moment it was hovering just above 800. So to say I was a tad skeptical of the rally’s staying power would be an understatement. On the other hand, if you’d told me then that not until December 21, 1982, would the Dow finally break through 1,000 for good, I might have said to hell with it and found another line of work. In fact, I had been right on the precipice of that decision for some time. Who starts a brokerage firm in the middle of a two-decade stock market slump? This was my third go at starting a business since I had set out on my own, shortly after finishing Stanford Business School. Part of me wondered, How many chances does one guy get in life?
What’s more, I was in a deep trough myself just then, carrying a six-figure debt. I owed money to Crocker Bank for a business loan I had used to buy out one of my partners. I also had a sheaf of personal loans that wound up in my pocket when I got divorced. I was now married again, but I had no assets to speak of. Helen and I were living with our baby, Katie, in a small apartment in Sausalito. Helen was selling real estate, while I was a year into launching my firm, an experiment in discounted stock trading made possible by the Securities and Exchange Commission’s test of deregulated commissions. I was bound for parts unknown.
That Tuesday, I had one overriding question. The answer would make or break my plans, as deregulation was about to become the law of the land after a one-year test period. What would Merrill Lynch do? Founded in 1914 by the legendary Charles Merrill, with a vision to bring “Wall Street to Main Street,” Merrill Lynch was the undisputed king of the retail brokerage market, and a billion-dollar-plus underwriter. It had branch offices from coast to coast, an army of thousands of highly motivated commissioned brokers, and a slogan known to everyone who watched TV or read the newspaper: “Merrill Lynch is bullish on America.” Charles Merrill had built his firm on the idea of opening up the world of investing to the middle class. It was a goal I admired. He was the first to experiment with salaried brokers back in the 1940s, addressing the serious conflict of interest that I had disliked for years (they backtracked from that model in the early ’70s under Don Regan’s leadership to incentivize its large herd of brokers). And the firm was hugely successful. Everybody said to me, “Wait until Merrill Lynch decides to go into your business. You are going to be crushed.”
I was worried, but Merrill was an entrenched member of the Wall Street establishment. It was still beholden to its many commissioned brokers, and its highly profitable investment banking and research businesses. It couldn’t just chuck all that out the window. Still, the more I thought about it, the more I was certain that Merrill would have to lower its commissions at least a little in response to deregulation. In which case, I feared, I’d be dead in the water as soon as I launched my business. No way my little firm could compete with an industry giant like Merrill.
All that was on my mind when I arrived at 120 Montgomery Street that Monday morning, early as usual (I liked to be at my desk by 6:30 a.m. when the market opened in New York); I took the elevator up to the 24th floor and the small office the handful of us occupied. I picked up my copy of the Wall Street Journal, and there on the front page was the news: “Merrill Lynch will raise securities brokerage fees on most transactions under $5000.” Was it true? “. . . will raise securities brokerage fees . . .”
Unbelievable. Here I’d been afraid that Merrill would lower its fees and meet my commission cuts and steal my opportunity. Instead, it had taken advantage of deregulation to raise its prices for the average guy and drop them for large institutions. Once I got over my shock, I was beaming. I saw an opportunity, and I meant to take full advantage of it. It had been a long road, with lots of bumps along the way. But on that day, Charles Schwab looked like it had a real chance in the marketplace. I remember saying to myself, I’ve got a hell of a business.
I have loved the idea of investing since I was a kid and my dad first showed me stock tables in the local paper. The idea that stocks captured a little bit of the magic in our economy and, if you worked at it, you could participate in that . . . well, that caught my imagination. That was exciting. Today, I remain more convinced than ever that investing is the individual’s path to financial freedom. It is how people can participate in a growing economy, beyond just earning a paycheck. I’m an optimist. And investing has always seemed to me to be the ultimate act of optimism. You’ve got to have confidence that the money you invest today is going to grow; otherwise, you might as well stuff it under the mattress. You have to believe tomorrow will be better than today.
But back in the ’70s when I was starting Schwab, I knew investing was deeply flawed. And I thought investors deserved better. Access to the markets came with outrageously high costs—average commissions and spreads could eat up nearly 10% of an investor’s money! Mutual funds, which pooled investors’ money together to be invested by a professional money manager, often carried 9% sales loads. That meant you needed to earn 9% on your investment before you’d break even. So much of those high costs were claimed to cover the “advice” that you were getting. But was it good advice, or just the price of entry? Wall Street had controlled commissions from its very first day under a buttonwood tree in 1792, where its founding members had established the New York Stock Exchange and agreed to do business only among themselves, and to never negotiate commissions.
So in a real way, Charles Schwab was born of my own frustration. I was an independent investor. I was passionate about the market. I did my own stock research. I believed in taking charge of my own financial destiny. I loved the thrill of the chase. The last thing I needed was some broker’s questionable advice about what to buy, and when to buy or sell. And I resented paying for services I wasn’t using. I was also deeply frustrated. For I had come to believe that the brokerage business had a nagging problem with conflicts of interests. I knew that the Wall Street big brokerage firms that were also investment banks—despite their so-called Chinese walls—couldn’t easily put the interests of individual investors first. The same was true for commissioned salespeople, many of whom made their living by trading in and out of stocks—not by building up their clients’ portfolios. Not their fault: it was just how the system worked.
But a new day had arrived. After years of mounting pressure for reform, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) had begun a bold experiment aimed at dismantling the century-old Wall Street cartel. Under the old system, fixed brokerage commissions were held in place by a web of regulations that carried the full weight of law. If you made a trade, you paid a high price, and the price was fixed. Or maybe not, this being Wall Street. Small traders had zero leverage, but big traders were getting bigger and had plenty of leverage, and lately they’d begun to use it. They had worked out an elaborate system of special favors, hidden discounts, side deals, and mutual back-scratching—anything to lower the cost of trading. Take, for example, the four-way ticket, a crazy system that broke commissions up into pieces, with the proceeds spread around to provide some benefit to the large institutions making the trades. In a four-way ticket, an institutional investor such as a pension or a mutual fund, would buy 10,000 shares of a stock, for example, with a commission that might have been, let’s say, $1 a share. One-fourth of that $10,000 commission would go to a research firm, who would provide proprietary research back to the investor; another quarter would go to reimbursing the investing institution for travel, under the auspices of “education”; another fourth went for entertainment such as a night out at a game or club, or a fancy dinner. And the last fourth would go to the brokerage. The same was true for a larger transaction of 100,000 shares. Only in that case there would be a $100,000 pie to be divided.
By the early 1970s, the system had become unwieldy. Something had to give. Institutions didn’t like it, the SEC didn’t like it, and Congress got involved. Bottom line: the power of the big traders was growing; the New York Stock Exchange was buckling under enormous pressure. Change was inevitable.
Description:
“To say Charles Schwab is an entrepreneur is actually an understatement. He really is a revolutionary.”—Phil Knight, co-founder of Nike, author of Shoe Dog **
The founder of The Charles Schwab Corporation recounts his ups and downs as he made stock investing, once the expensive and clubby reserve of the few, accessible to ordinary Americans.**
In this deeply personal memoir, Schwab describes his passion to have Main Street participate in the growing economy as investors and owners, not only earners. Schwab opens up about his dyslexia and how he worked around and ultimately embraced it, and about the challenges he faced while starting his fledgling company in the 1970s. A year into his grand experiment in discounted stock trading, living in a small apartment in Sausalito with his wife, Helen, and new baby, he carried a six-figure debt and a pocketful of personal loans. As it turned out, customers flocked to Schwab, leaving his small team scrambling with scarce resources and no road map to manage the company’s growth.
He recounts the company’s game-changing sale to Bank of America—and how, in the end, the merger almost doomed his organization. We learn about the clever and timely leveraged buyout he crafted to regain independence; the crushing stock market collapse of 1987, just weeks after the company had gone public; the dot-com meltdown of 2000 and its reverberating aftermath of economic stagnation, layoffs, and the company’s eventual reinvention; and how the company’s focus on managing risk protected it and its clients during the financial crisis in 2008, propelling its growth.
A remarkable story of a company succeeding by challenging norms and conventions through decades of change, Invested also offers unique insights and lifelong principles for readers—the values that Schwab has lived and worked by that have made him one of the most successful entrepreneurs of our time. Today, his eponymous company is one of the leading financial services firms in the world.
Advance praise for Invested
“I’ve admired Chuck Schwab for a long time. When you read this book, you’ll understand why.” —Warren E. Buffett
“This is a fascinating story that teaches you about the never-ending evolution of an entrepreneurial company, but even more about personal learning from that experience. So read, learn how to learn from experience, and enjoy.” —George P. Shultz, former secretary of Labor, Treasury, and State
Review
“Chuck Schwab provides an engaging look into the investing world, balanced between his penchant for risk-taking with his grace and humility. He crafts a creative and highly rewarding story of not just Charles Schwab, the company, but Charles Schwab, the person. There are life lessons in this book for everyone, from Wall Street to Main Street.” —Condoleezza Rice, former U.S. Secretary of State and Denning Professor in Global Business and the Economy at the Stanford Graduate School of Business
“By turns practical and personally insightful, Charles Schwab’s indefatigable spirit, sound judgement, and entrepreneurial experience shine through in Invested. Throughout his childhood and career, Chuck overcame challenges and set a standard of leadership and innovation throughout decades of change in our U.S. economic system.” —Jamie Dimon , chairman and CEO, JPMorgan Chase
“Like myself, Chuck is a dyslexic. He learned early on that he had his limits and therefore—unlike most nondyslexics—discovered the power of delegation. He discovered that business is all about people who share your vision and values but bring their own passion and strengths to the tasks. He realized early on that the world is full of people more capable than himself in ‘a thousand different ways.’ Most leaders and entrepreneurs never learn that simple lesson. It was his dyslexia that helped him create one of the most successful companies in the US. Invested is a must-read for anyone interested in working in a business or becoming an entrepreneur. An extraordinary life and book.” —Sir Richard Branson , founder of the Virgin Group
“Charles Schwab is a giant who transformed finance and investing for millions of Americans. His memoir is a textbook case on entrepreneurship and principled leadership.” —Hank Paulson, 74th Secretary of the Treasury
“Through Chuck’s unique perspective, Invested details Schwab’s history as they persevered through adversity while providing wisdom and encouragement along the way. I have admired and respected Chuck for many years. We share a passion for golf and how its challenges parallel those encountered in business.” —Phil Mickelson
“Chuck tells a story that very few can tell. It is a story of creativity, passion, and bravery trumping the odds. Chuck not only created the discount brokerage industry but grew a company in the face of market cycles and a rapidly changing and consolidating landscape. Chuck led the way in democratizing the market for the individual investor. I am proud to have been a partner with Chuck in the early days. I am especially proud to have him as a friend for the past fifty years.” —George R. Roberts, co-chairman and co-CEO, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts
“We learn best from the stories of others, and you’ll be hard pressed to find one so interesting, inspiring, and educational as this one! An enriching read from a great and principled man.” —Steve Forbes, chairman and editor inchief, Forbes
“Sharing his personal story of meeting and overcoming personal and business challenges that enabled the innovations enhancing the financial well-being of millions, Chuck Schwab’s Invested is full of invaluable insights into, and wise counsel about, building a successful business and successful personal investing. A readily accessible ‘real must-read’ for anyone interested in business and finance.” —Michael J. Boskin, professor of economics, Stanford University ; f ormer chair, President’s Council of Economic Advisers
“ Invested is a wonderful account of a textbook disruptor. By focusing on affordability and accessibility, what Chuck built in Charles Schwab has been a real blessing to mankind.” —Clayton Christensen , Kim B. Clark Professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School; author of The Innovator’s Dilemma
“For years Chuck Schwab was one of my fiercest competitors; now I consider him a friend. His book about building Charles Schwab into a revolutionary investment powerhouse is a must-read for anyone interested in what an audacious, high-integrity entrepreneur is capable of doing if he dreams big.” —Joe Ricketts, founder, former CEO, and former chairman, TD Ameritrade
“The fact that anyone in America can be an investor both enhances prosperity and reinforces the public’s buy-in to the concept of economic freedom. Few have done more to expand access to this form of direct participation in capitalism and free enterprise than my friend Chuck Schwab, and the story of how he did it belongs on the bookshelf of anyone interested in the evolution of investing over the past four decades.” —Paul Singer, founder of the Elliott Management Corporation
“From the beginning, one of Chuck’s great insights was that he could only create the business of his dreams by leaning heavily on emerging technologies. He bet big on data and never looked back. It changed investing forever.” —Thomas M. Siebel, CEO, C3.ai
About the Author
Charles Schwab is the founder, former CEO, and current chairman, of The Charles Schwab Corporation. Among the giants of the financial services industry, he is one of the most successful entrepreneurs and leaders in American business.
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
1
May Day
Tuesday, April 30, 1975. The day before what came to be known to people in financial services as May Day. I’m not sure if it was sunny or socked in with San Francisco fog. I had a lot on my mind. I do recall that investors had been in a good mood all spring. The Nixon impeachment nightmare was over, the Vietnam War was behind us, and the market was moving again; the Dow was up nearly 50% since late December. I’m sure I was as hopeful as anyone else. But I’d seen too much to believe the worst was over.
I was about to turn 38 in a couple of months. The Dow had been flirting with the magic 1,000 mark for the last 10 years, first breaking that milestone on November 14, 1972. At the moment it was hovering just above 800. So to say I was a tad skeptical of the rally’s staying power would be an understatement. On the other hand, if you’d told me then that not until December 21, 1982, would the Dow finally break through 1,000 for good, I might have said to hell with it and found another line of work. In fact, I had been right on the precipice of that decision for some time. Who starts a brokerage firm in the middle of a two-decade stock market slump? This was my third go at starting a business since I had set out on my own, shortly after finishing Stanford Business School. Part of me wondered, How many chances does one guy get in life?
What’s more, I was in a deep trough myself just then, carrying a six-figure debt. I owed money to Crocker Bank for a business loan I had used to buy out one of my partners. I also had a sheaf of personal loans that wound up in my pocket when I got divorced. I was now married again, but I had no assets to speak of. Helen and I were living with our baby, Katie, in a small apartment in Sausalito. Helen was selling real estate, while I was a year into launching my firm, an experiment in discounted stock trading made possible by the Securities and Exchange Commission’s test of deregulated commissions. I was bound for parts unknown.
That Tuesday, I had one overriding question. The answer would make or break my plans, as deregulation was about to become the law of the land after a one-year test period. What would Merrill Lynch do? Founded in 1914 by the legendary Charles Merrill, with a vision to bring “Wall Street to Main Street,” Merrill Lynch was the undisputed king of the retail brokerage market, and a billion-dollar-plus underwriter. It had branch offices from coast to coast, an army of thousands of highly motivated commissioned brokers, and a slogan known to everyone who watched TV or read the newspaper: “Merrill Lynch is bullish on America.” Charles Merrill had built his firm on the idea of opening up the world of investing to the middle class. It was a goal I admired. He was the first to experiment with salaried brokers back in the 1940s, addressing the serious conflict of interest that I had disliked for years (they backtracked from that model in the early ’70s under Don Regan’s leadership to incentivize its large herd of brokers). And the firm was hugely successful. Everybody said to me, “Wait until Merrill Lynch decides to go into your business. You are going to be crushed.”
I was worried, but Merrill was an entrenched member of the Wall Street establishment. It was still beholden to its many commissioned brokers, and its highly profitable investment banking and research businesses. It couldn’t just chuck all that out the window. Still, the more I thought about it, the more I was certain that Merrill would have to lower its commissions at least a little in response to deregulation. In which case, I feared, I’d be dead in the water as soon as I launched my business. No way my little firm could compete with an industry giant like Merrill.
All that was on my mind when I arrived at 120 Montgomery Street that Monday morning, early as usual (I liked to be at my desk by 6:30 a.m. when the market opened in New York); I took the elevator up to the 24th floor and the small office the handful of us occupied. I picked up my copy of the Wall Street Journal, and there on the front page was the news: “Merrill Lynch will raise securities brokerage fees on most transactions under $5000.” Was it true? “. . . will raise securities brokerage fees . . .”
Unbelievable. Here I’d been afraid that Merrill would lower its fees and meet my commission cuts and steal my opportunity. Instead, it had taken advantage of deregulation to raise its prices for the average guy and drop them for large institutions. Once I got over my shock, I was beaming. I saw an opportunity, and I meant to take full advantage of it. It had been a long road, with lots of bumps along the way. But on that day, Charles Schwab looked like it had a real chance in the marketplace. I remember saying to myself, I’ve got a hell of a business.
I have loved the idea of investing since I was a kid and my dad first showed me stock tables in the local paper. The idea that stocks captured a little bit of the magic in our economy and, if you worked at it, you could participate in that . . . well, that caught my imagination. That was exciting. Today, I remain more convinced than ever that investing is the individual’s path to financial freedom. It is how people can participate in a growing economy, beyond just earning a paycheck. I’m an optimist. And investing has always seemed to me to be the ultimate act of optimism. You’ve got to have confidence that the money you invest today is going to grow; otherwise, you might as well stuff it under the mattress. You have to believe tomorrow will be better than today.
But back in the ’70s when I was starting Schwab, I knew investing was deeply flawed. And I thought investors deserved better. Access to the markets came with outrageously high costs—average commissions and spreads could eat up nearly 10% of an investor’s money! Mutual funds, which pooled investors’ money together to be invested by a professional money manager, often carried 9% sales loads. That meant you needed to earn 9% on your investment before you’d break even. So much of those high costs were claimed to cover the “advice” that you were getting. But was it good advice, or just the price of entry? Wall Street had controlled commissions from its very first day under a buttonwood tree in 1792, where its founding members had established the New York Stock Exchange and agreed to do business only among themselves, and to never negotiate commissions.
So in a real way, Charles Schwab was born of my own frustration. I was an independent investor. I was passionate about the market. I did my own stock research. I believed in taking charge of my own financial destiny. I loved the thrill of the chase. The last thing I needed was some broker’s questionable advice about what to buy, and when to buy or sell. And I resented paying for services I wasn’t using. I was also deeply frustrated. For I had come to believe that the brokerage business had a nagging problem with conflicts of interests. I knew that the Wall Street big brokerage firms that were also investment banks—despite their so-called Chinese walls—couldn’t easily put the interests of individual investors first. The same was true for commissioned salespeople, many of whom made their living by trading in and out of stocks—not by building up their clients’ portfolios. Not their fault: it was just how the system worked.
But a new day had arrived. After years of mounting pressure for reform, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) had begun a bold experiment aimed at dismantling the century-old Wall Street cartel. Under the old system, fixed brokerage commissions were held in place by a web of regulations that carried the full weight of law. If you made a trade, you paid a high price, and the price was fixed. Or maybe not, this being Wall Street. Small traders had zero leverage, but big traders were getting bigger and had plenty of leverage, and lately they’d begun to use it. They had worked out an elaborate system of special favors, hidden discounts, side deals, and mutual back-scratching—anything to lower the cost of trading. Take, for example, the four-way ticket, a crazy system that broke commissions up into pieces, with the proceeds spread around to provide some benefit to the large institutions making the trades. In a four-way ticket, an institutional investor such as a pension or a mutual fund, would buy 10,000 shares of a stock, for example, with a commission that might have been, let’s say, $1 a share. One-fourth of that $10,000 commission would go to a research firm, who would provide proprietary research back to the investor; another quarter would go to reimbursing the investing institution for travel, under the auspices of “education”; another fourth went for entertainment such as a night out at a game or club, or a fancy dinner. And the last fourth would go to the brokerage. The same was true for a larger transaction of 100,000 shares. Only in that case there would be a $100,000 pie to be divided.
By the early 1970s, the system had become unwieldy. Something had to give. Institutions didn’t like it, the SEC didn’t like it, and Congress got involved. Bottom line: the power of the big traders was growing; the New York Stock Exchange was buckling under enormous pressure. Change was inevitable.